-
When this checklist applies
-
Step 1: Define the application window, not the resin name
-
Step 2: Verify the supplier's market position before you trust the claim
-
Step 3: Match the grade to the application, not the brochure
-
Step 4: Build a TCO model, not a price comparison
-
Step 5: Pilot on your own equipment
-
Step 6: Compare alternatives honestly
-
Step 7: Set exit terms before you sign
-
Caveats and common mistakes
I manage roughly $2.4M in annual raw material spend at a 300-person manufacturer. About 40% of that goes to engineering plastics—polycarbonate, polyurethane, TPU. Over the past six years, I've evaluated more than 20 suppliers, from tier-one players like Covestro and Teijin down to regional distributors. This is the checklist I use before I sign anything.
As of January 2025, it has saved my team about $40,000 in bad decisions—mostly by forcing us to slow down at the right moments.
When this checklist applies
Use it if you're buying PC, PU, TPU, or PC/ABS for any of these applications:
- Aviation interior components (polycarbonate aviation grades)
- Plastic card stock—ID cards, bank cards, transit passes
- Textile applications (TPU yarn for coatings, laminates, or elastics)
- Consumer goods (cutting boards, kitchen tools, appliance housings)
If you're buying commodity resin by the truckload and price is the only variable, this may be more process than you need. For everyone else: seven steps, in order.
Step 1: Define the application window, not the resin name
It's tempting to think "polycarbonate is polycarbonate." It isn't.
Polycarbonate aviation grades have to pass FAR 25.853 vertical burn, smoke density, and toxicity tests. Plastic card stock needs flexural modulus, printability, and wear resistance. Same polymer family, completely different spec sheets. Suppliers know this. But some will still quote you "PC" without asking what it's for.
In my first year on the job, I made the classic rookie mistake: assumed "standard" meant the same thing to every vendor. It cost us a $1,200 redo when the material failed a printability test we'd never specified. Now I put the application, the operating window, and the failure tolerance in writing before I request a single quote. What's the application? What's the operating window—temperature, UV exposure, chemical contact? What happens if it fails—cosmetic reject or field failure? Answer those three questions first.
Step 2: Verify the supplier's market position before you trust the claim
If someone says "we're a market leader in polycarbonate," ask for the basis. Per publicly available capacity data (e.g., S&P Global Commodity Insights, 2024), both Covestro and Teijin rank among the top global PC producers. But exact shares shift year to year, and "leader" can mean volume, revenue, or a niche grade.
I won't quote a precise Covestro vs. Teijin market share number here, because I don't trust any single source for that figure. Pull the latest numbers from at least two industry reports before you build a business case around a leadership claim. What matters more is capacity fit: can they actually supply your volume, in your region, with the lead time you need? For our annual PC volume—roughly 90 metric tons—we needed a supplier with regional inventory. A global leader with no local stock is worse than a regional player with two weeks of safety stock.
Step 3: Match the grade to the application, not the brochure
"TPU yarn" is not one product. It's a performance spec—hydrolysis resistance, elongation, abrasion, and heat stability all vary by grade.
Covestro's Desmopan TPU line, for example, includes grades specified for textile and yarn applications where hydrolysis resistance matters. Some are bio-based or recycled; others are standard virgin resin. But I still ask for 70°C/95% RH hydrolysis test data at 500+ hours. Why? Because "hydrolysis-resistant" means different things to different suppliers, and I've seen the claim fall apart at 300 hours. And don't assume a recycled grade performs identically to virgin—ask for the physical property data for the specific grade you're considering.
For aviation PC, ask for the burn test report and smoke toxicity data, not just the TDS. For plastic card stock, ask for printability and flex-cycle data. If the supplier can't produce application-specific test data within 48 hours, that tells you something about their technical support.
Step 4: Build a TCO model, not a price comparison
The numbers said go with Vendor B—12% cheaper per kilogram, similar specs on paper. My gut said stick with our existing supplier. I ran the TCO model anyway.
B's "cheaper" material had a 4% higher scrap rate in our pilot, and its drying requirements added 18 minutes per batch. Over a year, that erased the 12% advantage and then some. My gut was right—but only because I remembered that B had been slow to answer technical questions during the RFQ. Slow to answer usually means slow to help when something breaks at 2 AM.
Build the model with these inputs: unit price, freight, scrap rate, drying energy, changeover time, and rework rate. For reference, standard PC grades typically ran $2.50–4.00/kg and TPU $3.00–6.00/kg in our Q3 2024 quotes. Verify current pricing—rates move with feedstock and freight. And if you can quantify technical support responsiveness, add a line for it—I score it 1–5 based on average email response time during the RFQ.
Step 5: Pilot on your own equipment
Every supplier will send you a data sheet. Some will send free samples. Very few will send a material that behaves the same on your extruder as it does in their lab.
Run a small batch—200 kg is usually enough—on your actual equipment. Measure scrap rate, cycle time, and any downstream processing issues. Document everything in the same spreadsheet you use for production runs, because you'll want to compare side-by-side later. If I remember correctly, our last pilot caught a moisture sensitivity issue that never showed up in the TDS. The material needed 4 hours of drying at 120°C instead of the 2 hours the datasheet suggested. That's a scheduling problem, not a defect—but it would have wrecked our first production week.
Step 6: Compare alternatives honestly
Say you're choosing between TPU and silicone for a cutting board application. Both are non-porous. Both are flexible. Both handle heat reasonably well. But they're not interchangeable.
TPU has better tear resistance and doesn't pick up odors the way silicone can after repeated contact with onions and garlic. Silicone, on the other hand, handles sustained high heat (400°F+) better and rarely yellows the way some TPU grades do over time. Which is "better" depends on whether the end user is prepping raw meat—TPU wins on knife-scar resistance—or baking, where silicone wins on heat tolerance.
If a supplier tells you their material is universally superior, that's a red flag. Honest suppliers will tell you where their product doesn't fit. The ones who won't are the ones you'll have trouble with later.
Step 7: Set exit terms before you sign
Last year, a customer demanded a grade change with 48 hours' notice. Normally I'd run a three-week qualification. There was no time. I called our Covestro rep directly, got the technical data sheet the same day, and made the call on incomplete information. It worked out—but I don't recommend it.
What makes that kind of squeeze survivable is having exit terms already in place: a 90-day termination clause, a price-adjustment formula tied to a published index, and a documented handover process for tooling and specifications. If you don't have those, you're locked in whether you like it or not.
Caveats and common mistakes
Three things I've seen go wrong, repeatedly:
- Using one spec sheet for multiple applications. Aviation PC and plastic card PC are different grades with different test requirements. Don't let a supplier quote "PC" and assume it meets both.
- Comparing unit price instead of landed cost. A 12% discount disappears fast when scrap rate goes up 4% and drying time adds 18 minutes per batch. Run the TCO model.
- Skipping the pilot because the sample looked fine. Lab samples and production batches are not the same thing. I've seen the difference show up in batch three, not batch one.
One last thing: market share claims are not a procurement strategy. Covestro and Teijin are both capable suppliers. The question isn't who's bigger—it's who fits your application, your volume, and your risk tolerance. Get the data, run the pilot, and keep the exit terms in writing.